How does insurance company determine fault

In this page

Understanding Car Insurance Amount You Pay

Determining fault after a vehicular accident is a crucial aspect for insurance companies. It impacts the claims process, premiums, and future coverage. But how does an insurance company decide who’s at fault? This article explores the in-depth process insurance adjusters follow to determine fault, from evidence analysis to understanding traffic laws and examining negligence.

How does insurance company determine fault

How Does an Insurance Company Determine Fault?

Determining Fault: The Basics

Definition of Fault

In the realm of auto insurance, fault refers to the responsibility for an accident. It determines who must bear the financial burden of damages, from physical harm to property damage.

Importance of Determining Fault

Deciphering who’s at fault is fundamental. It influences premiums, claims processing, and coverage eligibility.

Understanding Insurance Adjusters’ Role

Responsibilities of an Insurance Adjuster

An insurance adjuster, or claims adjuster, is the point person who investigates incidents to determine fault. They review the claim, evaluate damages, and decide who is liable.

Process of Investigation

The adjuster gathers and analyzes information from the incident, like police reports, witness statements, and physical evidence. They also consult local traffic laws to understand if any violations occurred.

Analyzing Evidence

Type of Evidence

Key evidence includes photographs of the accident scene, vehicle damage, any recorded video, and medical reports if injuries occurred. This data helps paint a vivid picture of what transpired.

Role of Evidence in Determining Fault

Evidence is instrumental in piecing together the incident’s sequence. It supports or refutes claims and can conclusively determine who is liable.

State Traffic Laws and Regulations

Importance of Traffic Laws

Traffic laws are rules of the road. They dictate right of way, speed limits, and driving behavior.

Impact on Fault Determination

Traffic law violations often indicate fault. For instance, if a driver was speeding or failed to yield, they’re likely at fault.

Negligence and Its Types

Definition of Negligence

Negligence is the failure to behave with the level of care that a reasonable person would have exercised under the same circumstances.

Types of Negligence

Different forms of negligence, like contributory, comparative, and gross negligence, can impact the fault determination.

Role of Negligence in Fault Determination

In some cases, multiple parties may share fault. A driver could be found partially negligent, affecting the claim payout.


Insurance companies determine fault through a thorough investigation, involving evidence analysis, traffic law scrutiny, and negligence assessment. An insurance adjuster spearheads this process, ensuring a fair and accurate determination.


1. Does the police report always determine fault?

No, while a police report is vital evidence, insurance adjusters also consider other factors.

2. What happens if both drivers are at fault?

In many states, this falls under comparative negligence rules where fault is split between both parties.

3. How does fault affect my insurance premium?

If you’re determined to be at fault in an accident, your insurance premium may increase.

4. Can fault determination be disputed?

Yes, you can dispute a fault determination if you believe it to be inaccurate.

5. What is the role of witnesses in determining fault?

Witnesses can provide valuable insights into how the accident unfolded, supporting or challenging the claims made by drivers.

Recomended for You